88594 Branding Branding

Possible future First Lady of the United States, Melania Trump, wife of Republican Party nominee, Donald Trump, recently delivered a most memorable speech at the 2016 Republican National Convention in Cleveland, OH. In fact, listening to it many of us experienced a kind of déjà vu. We had heard these words before, hadn't we? Indeed we had, during the 2008 Democratic Convention, in a speech given by Michelle Obama.

Flash forward to the immediate aftermath. Twitter went a-flutter with thousands of comments about the alleged plagiarism. Facebook soon followed and within hours, news networks had jumped on board and were running with the story. Early naysayers who had sided with Mrs. Trump soon hushed their adamant denials, and by the next morning Meredith McIver, a staff writer for the Trump campaign, had taken responsibility for the "mistake" with the words: “This was my mistake, and I feel terrible for the chaos that have caused Melania and the Trumps, as well as to Mrs. Obama,” McIver said in her statement. “No harm was meant.”

So what has the Melania Trump speech debacle taught us about plagiarism?

1) People Still Care About Plagiarism
This point may seem moot for some but in an age where copy and paste seems to be the two favorite functions on many students' laptop keyboards, the public's reaction to the incident shows that people do care about authenticity, honesty, and speaking one's mind (with one's own words). Perhaps many of us cast a blind eye at bits of text copied from the web, perhaps we feel "borrowing" is the name of the game in today's freewheeling internet fueled culture but, when something big is at stake, something as big as, let's say, the Presidency of the United States, then yes, we care.

2) Words Represent Who We Are
The reason why there's been such an outcry probably also has much to do with how we feel about words themselves and the power they have to let others know who we are and what we're about. Anyone who has been at the receiving end of a bold-faced lie knows just how slighted one can feel. We expect our leaders to be strong, to have character, and to speak their minds. When this trust is broken, people respond strongly because the breech seems to represent a lack of ethics, a lack of character and further imply that the speaker has nothing good to say on their own. For the listeners, feelings of acceptance or tolerance are replaced by feelings of doubt, mistrust, or worry.

3) If You Must Borrow, Cite!
Think of just how different and downright unconventional (and dare we say consensus building) Melania Trump's speech would have been if she has cited portions of Mrs. Obama's 2008 speech, clearly and brazenly. She could have mentioned what Mrs. Obama said word for word and then spoken about what those words mean to her, using, in effect, someone else's words as a lead in to her own ideas, her own experiences. Undoubtedly, many would have been shocked but a well-placed nod to the current First Lady would have shown that Mrs. Trump was capable of taking her inspiration from another strong female, even a Democratic one.

3) It Changes the Discourse
In his article "Why the plagiarism allegations against Melania Trump matter for her husband's campaign" journalist David Lauter of The LA Times hit the nail on the head when he posed the argument that the plagiarism charges leveled against Melania Trump matter because they "overshadowed" much of day two of the Republican Convention and effectively changed what was on people's minds, away from thinking about policy and instead, had them thinking about the accusations. Lautner says that by the end "of the convention’s 96 hours, more than 18 had vanished into the maw of Melania Trump’s speech. That’s time Trump will never get back." Accusations of misconduct or wrongdoing foster suspicion. Much like gossip, scandal appeals to people on a primal level, tending to sway them away from loftier or more productive thoughts and into a much different kind of discourse.

In business, it's essential that our words mirror our actions and vice-versa. Saying one thing and doing another erodes trust. Appropriating the language of another might not always be deemed plagiarism but, at the very least, it makes the speaker look less confident, more like an upstart taking their cues from someone they deem better than themselves. Instead of looking capable, the plagarist or copycat comes off as incapable to lead and unwilling to do the hard work of speaking their mind. The American public still cares about plagiarism because they still care about the truth. We all hope for honesty and forthrightness in our dealings with other people. When we feel we can no longer take stock in what someone is telling us, it's extremely hard to preserve the relationship. When we err in our judgment and make an ethical misstep we undermine our own authority and, if we don't correct our ways (and fast), we potentially open the door to gossip, suspicion, and doubt. So what has the Melania Trump speech debacle taught us about plagiarism? Answer: Dont do it. Give credit to those who are due their due. Speak in accord with actions. Honesty still matters and we're happy it does.


Williamka's picture

Williamka (not verified)

Oct 10, 2016 11:04 PM
kaiser pharmacy walnut creek

family health center kalamazoo mi [url=https://www.clippings.me/diethylpropion]buy diethylpropion online[/url] foot and ankle doctor

GeorgeLer's picture

GeorgeLer (not verified)

Oct 15, 2016 12:45 PM
pass drug test kit

what are biotin pills good for buy methylphenidate hydrochloride tramadol online no prescription overnight delivery

Stuartot's picture

Stuartot (not verified)

Oct 17, 2016 12:47 PM
24 hour pharmacy santa barbara

steroids in pill form reductil kaufen online coby kyros 4gb tablet

StuartGop's picture

StuartGop (not verified)

Jul 03, 2017 09:37 PM

k payday loan upon online payday loan best payday loans
t generic cialis online the cheap generic cialis generic cialis
c buy provigil here modafinil price provigil online

Davidnuh's picture

Davidnuh (not verified)

Aug 11, 2017 07:12 AM
Jamesgrark's picture

Jamesgrark (not verified)

Sep 21, 2017 08:59 AM

o cialis are
against cheap cialis
cialis price

Williamnof's picture

Williamnof (not verified)

Oct 09, 2017 09:59 PM

o buy levitra early cheap levitra cheap levitra

JasonboM's picture

JasonboM (not verified)

Feb 12, 2017 02:45 AM

study ended this [url=http://onlinecasinos-x.com/]online casinos[/url] where you can conquer genuine funds with the serve of this lightPlaying [url=http://onlinecasinos-x.com/free-casino-bonus.html]casino bonus[/url]

doBus's picture

doBus (not verified)

Mar 06, 2017 09:10 AM

oviewb [url=http://buyviagra24ph.com]generic viagra[/url]
kideao http://buyviagra24ph.com

xvBus's picture

xvBus (not verified)

Mar 06, 2017 11:58 PM

nlikel [url=http://buyviagra24ph.com]here[/url]
oeasyt [url=http://buyviagra24ph.com]viagra[/url]

ctBus's picture

ctBus (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 04:59 AM

ckepto http://buycialis24ph.com
rladyo http://buycialis24ph.com

bbExect's picture

bbExect (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 05:22 AM

zablel http://buycialis24ph.com
unearlyg http://buycialis24ph.com

eaBus's picture

eaBus (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 08:25 AM

cplainh [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]can you buy cialis over the counter[/url]
neachp buy cialis

dtExect's picture

dtExect (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 11:04 AM

hhavingn cialis
hraisedq http://buycialis24ph.com

pmBus's picture

pmBus (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 11:48 AM

wwordsw http://buycialis24ph.com
iwalkedd [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]cialis[/url]

yyblash's picture

yyblash (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 12:56 PM

achangeb cialis samples
ygentlemenk [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]http://buycialis24ph.com[/url]

uvBus's picture

uvBus (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 02:58 PM

fcasen http://buycialis24ph.com
rlostj http://buycialis24ph.com

gqExect's picture

gqExect (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 03:09 PM
gjblash's picture

gjblash (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 04:37 PM

bmiddlee [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]buy cialis online pharmacy[/url]
isomethingd can you buy cialis over the counter

ksBus's picture

ksBus (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 06:17 PM

wpeoplea buy cialis generic tadalafil
pwatchedc http://buycialis24ph.com

joExect's picture

joExect (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 07:25 PM

oyou'lll http://buycialis24ph.com
zman'sz [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]buy cialis[/url]

lyblash's picture

lyblash (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 07:58 PM

wcaptainf [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]enter here[/url]
elivedw cialis samples

goblash's picture

goblash (not verified)

Mar 07, 2017 11:32 PM

bfartherz http://buycialis24ph.com
xwatchede buy cialis online

lbExect's picture

lbExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 12:42 AM

canyn http://buycialis24ph.com
lcomeo http://buycialis24ph.com

cvBus's picture

cvBus (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 02:08 AM

flookedl [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]cialis[/url]
bweu http://buycialis24ph.com

vzblash's picture

vzblash (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 03:16 AM

oconfidenceb [url=http://buy-provigil.bid]buy-provigil.bid[/url]
hhillt http://buy-lyrica.bid

ouExect's picture

ouExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 03:22 AM

hwallu [url=http://clomid-rx.bid]clomid for men[/url]
mwasp http://buy-lyrica.bid

upblash's picture

upblash (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 06:29 AM

lheavyb lyrica
oaccordinge http://buy-provigil.bid

iwBus's picture

iwBus (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 06:58 AM

owhomk http://buy-provigil.bid
llikedk http://clomid-rx.bid

nhExect's picture

nhExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 07:12 AM

osceneo http://clomid-rx.bid
anobleb buy real viagra online

rkblash's picture

rkblash (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 10:11 AM

atogetherq http://buy-provigil.bid
opresentlyl http://buy-lyrica.bid

taBus's picture

taBus (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 10:41 AM

bcountenanceg http://clomid-rx.bid
hpassf buy clomid online usa

ncExect's picture

ncExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 11:59 AM

nmorningg [url=http://viagrarx.party]best place to buy viagra online[/url]
fcornera http://viagrarx.party

wkblash's picture

wkblash (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 01:19 PM

mproudi [url=http://buy-provigil.bid]can you buy provigil in mexico[/url]
wsupposedv http://buy-lyrica.bid

tgBus's picture

tgBus (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 02:46 PM

thoweverg http://buy-lyrica.bid
mhourf buy provigil canada

teExect's picture

teExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 05:12 PM

ibeforex [url=http://buy-provigil.bid]enter here[/url]
qpastr [url=http://viagrarx.party]generic viagra[/url]

nsBus's picture

nsBus (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 06:20 PM

mtowardsg buy viagra without doctor prescription
ghearty [url=http://buy-provigil.bid]provigil vs nuvigil[/url]

zoExect's picture

zoExect (not verified)

Mar 08, 2017 10:57 PM

wpassingf [url=http://viagrarx.party]http://viagrarx.party[/url]
vwhichv http://buy-provigil.bid

lsblash's picture

lsblash (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 12:14 AM

olikedz [url=http://viagrarx.party]viagra[/url]
ssamet http://buy-provigil.bid

gpPonge's picture

gpPonge (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 12:30 AM

ncomest http://viagrarx.party
hbreakfasty viagrarx.party

viagra without a doctor prescription's picture

viagra without ... (not verified)

Jan 31, 2018 03:16 PM
Add new comment | Innovatory

no prescription viagra viagra without a doctor prescription viagra without a doctor prescription http://viagrawithoutdoctorprescr.bid http://viagrawithoutdoctorprescr.bid

edPonge's picture

edPonge (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 03:29 AM

llossw lyrica coupons
rglassz [url=http://buy-lyrica.bid]gabapentin[/url]

qgblash's picture

qgblash (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 04:09 AM

kcarriagey [url=http://clomid-rx.bid]here[/url]
nafterwardsl http://viagrarx.party

olExect's picture

olExect (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 04:29 AM

awouldn'tf http://buy-provigil.bid
iyoungf http://buy-lyrica.bid

xaBus's picture

xaBus (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 04:50 AM

nhealthw neurontin
ssorryn http://buy-provigil.bid

ioPonge's picture

ioPonge (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 06:42 AM

sseemsx [url=http://buy-lyrica.bid]buy lyrica without a script [/url]
gconditionl [url=http://clomid-rx.bid]clomid-rx.bid[/url]

axblash's picture

axblash (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 07:53 AM

klongu [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]cost cialis generic drugs[/url]
d'emp http://buycialispharm.com

spExect's picture

spExect (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 08:36 AM

lheldi http://buycialispharm.com
cseaty [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]generic cialis 20 mg[/url]

veBus's picture

veBus (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 09:40 AM

oagoh [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]viagra half dose cialis pills[/url]
bfancym sell cialis pharmacy

gfblash's picture

gfblash (not verified)

Mar 09, 2017 11:12 AM

wsirt http://buycialispharm.com
ncauser [url=http://buycialis24ph.com]what doo cialis pills look like[/url]

Add a comment.